Thursday 19 April 2012

Media and Male Body Image

Now it is no longer only women who have body image issues as men are bombarded with images of the ideal body type, which they aspire to but is out of reach for most (Ricciardelli, Clow and White 2010).  They worry about not being muscular enough, too much body fat, the size of their penis and hair loss.  This is known as the Adonis complex. 

The mesomorph body type is often portrayed as the ideal body type by men's magazines.  The ectomorph is often featured in clothing advertisements as clothes fit this body type better.  The endomorph is rarely on show in the media (apart from the before shot, pre-diet and exercise) even although it would be the most common body shape amongst men.

Jason Statham

If you take a look at Men's Health magazine website, you will be confronted with articles such as 24 hours to a 6 pack, burn fat with morning stretches and beat hair loss.  All of these project to the male reader what he should look like or what he should be aspiring to look like.  The focus is very much on appearance and the celebrity male is often portrayed as having the ideal body type.  The Men's Health article '10 Hollywood muscle workouts' shows the reader how they too can accomplish a mesomorphic body like Mark Wahlberg in The Fighter or Gerard Butler in 300.  Furthermore, advertising in these magazines include this so-called ideal body type, for example, Abercrombie & Fitch are known for their advertisements featuring nearly naked muscular men.  
Abercrombie & Fitch advertisement

Mark Wahlberg, The Fighter

Gerard Butler, 300

George Clooney (in Armani) and girlfriend Stacey Keibler (in Marchesa), Oscars 2012

A study was conducted last year, which found that 80.7% of men talk about their and other male bodies (the inverted male gaze has developed, in other words, the male gaze is no longer limited to women but extends to men looking at other men (Patterson and Elliott 2002)), which leads to them being dissatisfied with their own body.  Furthermore, 35% of men would happily die a year earlier in exchange for their ideal body.  This can, as it has for some time for women, "contribute to clinical issues ranging from low self-esteem to Body Dysmorphic Disorder" (Ricciardelli, Clow and White 2010 p.73). 


Men aspire to look like these film stars but also aspire to their lifestyle in general such as fashion and grooming and this is reflected in the magazines.  For example, the cover of GQ magazine below features Ryan Gosling who is going to show the reader how to dress like a movie star.  The message is that "fashion [is] promoted as the key to financial success." (Ricciardelli, Clow and White 2010 p.75

 
This increased interest in fashion has led to London Collections: Men (LC: M) launching in June and will involve three full days showcasing men's fashion.


"The male body is subject to a continuous scrutiny - it is objectified, exploited and monitored" (Boni 2002 p.467).  The media encourages men to treat their body as a project (Patterson and Elliott 2002) to work on "through buying products and services [in order that] a man can change his embodied self and, thus make himself into the man he wants to be" (Ricciardelli, Clow and White 2010 p.74). 

Thursday 12 April 2012

H&M Red Carpet Conscious Collection

Following on from the Bafta Awards 2012 and ethical fashion post (13/02/12), H&M launched its red carpet conscious collection today.  The fast fashion retailer has produced clothing, which is made from organic cotton, hemp and recycled polyester. The prices range from £7.99 to £199.99, however, the majority of clothes are £19.99 or under.


The retailer has utilised celebrities to endorse the range by wearing the garments on the red carpet, thereby increasing awareness and encouraging consumers to purchase ethical fashion.

Michelle Williams, Oscars 2012
  
Amanda Seyfried, In Time London premiere

Kristin Davis, Vanity Fair event

Viola Davis, Santa Barbara Film Festival
Consumers tend to purchase non-ethical fashion over ethical fashion for several reasons, including it being viewed as unfashionable and expensive.  Joergens (2006) found that "price is the most decisive factor" (p.363) and found that participants "did not perceive the [ethical] garments illustrated as stylish or fashionable" (p.364). 


However, the conscious collection is both fashionable and affordable in addition to being ethical.  The collection is ethical glamour on a budget bringing ethical fashion to the mass market. 


By a well known retailer offering ethical collections, it raises consumer awareness of the ethics behind clothing.  As the diagram below shows ethical personal products (which also included cosmetics) only accounted for 4.1% of ethical consumerism in 2011 but this could increase significantly if other retailers follow in H&M's footsteps.  

Ethical Consumerism in the UK by sector by value (%), 2011 (Key Notes)
  
However, Black (2008) stated that a Cambridge university survey found that consumers in 2008 purchased one third more clothes than in 2004 (p.14). Such clothing is discarded after just a few wears perhaps even after one wear and heads to landfill.  Fast fashion also relies on cheap labour.  Therefore it could be argued that ethical fast fashion is an oxymoron.  

Friday 6 April 2012

Tweens, Fashion and Celebrity

On Saturday, in Los Angeles, the 25th annual Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards 2012 took place.  The awards show is aimed at the viewers of Nickelodeon, which is primarily tweens, with their favourite stars of film, television and music walking down the orange carpet.  For those of you who are unfamiliar with this term, tweens are generally aged anywhere between 6 and 12.  They are essentially any child who is in a hurry to grow up, in other words, they are teenagers before their time.

Some of their favourite film stars including Emma Stone, Kristen Stewart and Selena Gomez made an appearance on the orange carpet at the awards show.  Tween girls aspire to look and dress like their favourite stars and the marketing industry seeks to profit from this.

Emma Stone in Antonio Berardi 

Kristen Stewart in Stella McCartney

Selena Gomez in Dolce and Gabbana

In the 21st century, the marketing industry began to target tweens, as they have money to spend more so than any other generation did at their age (Lindstrom 2004 p.1), they influence their parents when making purchasing decisions (Lindstrom 2004 p.2) and to access customers early on in their lives in the hope that if they catch them young they can hold onto them.

The marketing industry encourages tweens to grow up quickly (the industry uses the acronym KAGOY (kids are getting older younger)) with the use of a strategy called "age up" (Castleberry and Merrier 2008) which involves selling fashion items which appear to be aimed at teenagers when in fact it is for tweens who want to appear 'cool'.  This, marketers know has and will continue to make them a considerable amount of money.  However, it has led to controversial clothing, such as padded bras and swimwear being sold in Primark, Abercrombie Kids and Asda amongst others, which parents argue are not age appropriate and has seen the launch of the Let Girls be Girls Campaign



There has also been much controversy about the use of child models in the fashion industry including 10 year old, Thylane Lena-Rose Blondeau in French Vogue and the message this sends to tween girls.

Thylane Lena-Rose Blondeau, French Vogue, December 2010

On the one hand, it could be argued that fashion brands, magazines and marketing executives are to blame for the premature sexualisation of tween girls.  On the other hand, the blame could be placed on the celebrities, who tweens idolise, for being inappropriate role models.

Sunday 1 April 2012

Celebrity Culture

The world today is obsessed with celebrity from what they are wearing to whose dating who.  People flock to the cinema, read about their favourite stars in celebrity gossip magazines and watch the premieres and festivals admiring the glamour especially the dresses as was witnessed with the recent Titanic 3D and The Hunger Games premieres.

Kate Winslet in Jenny Packham, Titanic 3D premiere, London

Elizabeth Banks in Bill Blass, The Hunger Games Premiere, London 

Jennifer Lawrence in Prabal Gurung, The Hunger Games Premiere, Los Angeles
        
There are two schools of thought on celebrity.  On the one hand, some theorists view celebrity as cultural decline.  Boorstin (1987) falls within this camp as already discussed in the Berlin Film Festival 2012 post (19/02/12).  On the other hand, other theorists view celebrity as populist democracy stating celebrity culture has resulted in social levelling as anyone can now become famous regardless of their background.  Consequently, they argue, it is no longer only white male aristocrats who are famous.  This has led to more women than ever before becoming famous actresses but with this has come the focus on their weight and appearance, rather than their acting ability, which has led to body image issues.








Rojek (2001) explains our obsession with all things celebrity as being due to the decline of religion and magic.  He argues that the majority of people in the Western world no longer go to church but are united in their opinions on celebrities and view them as God like.


Fans desperate to reach out to George Clooney at The Oscars

Do you enjoy the glamour of the red carpet viewing it as escapism and view film stars as God like and aspire to be the next big thing?  Or do you agree with Boorstin that these people and associated events represent cultural decline?